1934 Goudey Jimmy Foxx #1

I’m into the overall presentation here. The centering looks great, and the color and image come through really well. The staining is noticeable, but it’s not a big issue for me.

My gut says bottom of the top tier or top of the second tier. Either way, the eye appeal is really, really good here. Going with the former as the surface, edges, and corners are so solid.

Just a solid example all around. No glaring flaws that would hurt my viewing experience aside from honest wear from time.

T/B centering and the inconsistent tone are the main issues on this awesome card.

Nice looking Jimmy for sure. Image looks great and centering not distracting. The staining/toning is what keeps this one from higher. grade.

These colors pop

Slips into the A- band with top end eye appeal to me, as toning is alongside corners an aspect my eye tends to not care so much about. The centering is almost in that bullseye and the central image is dynamite. If the stain encroached on The Double X himself, different eye appeal story.

nice looking card with a solid image and strong colors. Borders are an opportunity from the toning, to the centering and to the border sizes A card easy to enjoy as a solid mid-level card

Excellent image and color. Some toning around the borders and soiling on the upper left.