1950 Bowman Jackie Robinson #22

The staining distracts quite a bit. Paper loss as well. Image still shows well.

While the centering shift and staining make obvious impact on aesthetics, the aspect that I factor in most is the wear that crowds Jackie's face. Had that been farther afield and more serendipitously placed, like the far top left patch of paper loss, the eye appeal would be less impacted. That said, likely surpasses the expected eye appeal level of the numerical grade by a few clicks.