1958 Topps Jim Brown #62

centering carries the card but way to much surface wear that impacts the colors, image and overall eye appeal

The surface wear and the fisheyes distract a lot for me.

Pretty well centered with nice corners. The black show quite a bit of print snow which catches the eye but the excellent framing provides for an attractive eye appeal example.

Good overall eye appeal, which is a feat as this card has as many endemic eye appeal flaws as perhaps any in the hobby. The centering sits a touch low though remains on the good side. Corners and edges are strengths. The focus is better than many. This leaves the usual PD issues in the challenging black, which is what makes the most impact on aesthetic appeal.