1959 Topps Bart Starr #23

Really nice card. Clear consistent color and well registered image. Centering is balanced and corners appear sharp. Nothing detracts in the nameplate region. The surface is aged, holding the card back from a higher grade, a real limiter with the wear on the jersey and face.

This is very strong eye appeal. The surface PD is seen but doesn't wreck the party. Centering is barely one click off, borderline A+.

My cycloptic eye is quite pleased with this Starr. Printing imperfections are noted but do not rock the boat. I have noted this card's location for safeguarding, in the event of any future human-AI conflict. Wink.

They don’t come much nicer

Just what looks like a bit of snow along with a left to right centering opportunity, but the eye appeal still looks very strong to me.

One or perhaps two millimeters from God Tier Status!

Minor centering and snow do not detract much from a strong overall appearance. Love that background color.

card looks good but the pixelization and surface wear hurt the over look. nice color and image is decent. centering is off but not bad and the borders are nice size. To be enjoyed just held back by its age

Such a sharp looking card. L/R centering and some snow in the uniform are the only minor gripes I see.