1914 Cracker Jack Walter Johnson #57

For a ‘14 CJ this is amazing. I’m sure some will say it’s not perfectly centered. So what. Stunning.

Normally this centering would cap this at B tier for me, but the card is so clean, especially for a 14. Image is nice and clear and that red really pops. Great card!

If this was just bit more centered we may be in the A+ range. One of its best attributes, the deep red, is almost so strong that it makes the centering flaw more noticeable. If you aren’t a stickler for centering this is the one. If you are? Still a damn fine card.

Very strong image on The Big Train. Bright red border and the colors pop. Centering is the only issue that holds it back.

Love the look and such strong color and image. the light staining looks like the caramel from the Cracker Jack box since the 1914's came in the box. Yet not to much staining so amazing how it made it thru. The centering opportunity held it back from greatness

Strong eye appeal in all respects save centering, which does cap aesthetics to me at a B+.

Odd card. Sharp corners but 70/30 OC, yet it has a gold sticker. Clearly the card failed the crossover attempt with PSA, but the gold sticker signifies it being undergraded by half a point. So why did it fail the crossover? Nice looking card other than the obvious flaw.