1909 E90-1 American Caramel Ty Cobb

Surface wear and t/b centering hold it back for me.

the colors and the image are good and that helps me enjoy the card. The border size issue, off centering, and corner damage along with the stain by the shoulders holds it back

The upper right corner does draw my eye. Staining by the shoulder and the L/R centering does lower the eye-appeal for me.

Centering, corner wear that enters my, "I notice" zone, and most of all that damage in the center left do conspire to impact eye appeal here.