1957 Topps Mickey Mantle #95

Just too much yellowing to be higher.

A standout example aesthetically of a card that almost always has one flaw that sends the eye appeal into the C Tier. If it isn't bad centering, it's blurry. Or severely tilted. There are some flaws here, but I will steal a phrase I saw and liked and say the flaws are not "loud."

Really nice centering but misses the A range for me due to some surface snow and toning.

Excellent centering with a slight tilt. The borders are toned a little dark and there are minor surface issues, but still looks great overall.

Nearly A+ centering with toned borders and some print snow the only issues I notice.

love the look of the card and the colors and image are good the card is off centered and borders can be brighter. But overall a great card

Beautiful example here. So close to A+ for me but held back ever so slightly by a subtle tilt and a tiny bit of snow.

Pulp Fiction: "I say GODDAMN!" This is a breath from perfect centering! Wow. The eye appeal is THERE in spades. "A" all the way.

Fantastic example of one of my absolute favorite cards of all time. Very mild tilt and print are the only flaws that impact the eye appeal to me, but they do not jar it from the A level. Big fan of this example.

Subtle tilt and some snow in the background are the only things that draw my eye. Otherwise, a beautiful card.