1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311

An easy test, but PSA finally got the grade correct. I can live with severe creases, but I'd need the centering to be there. This one doesn't quite do it for me, but it's a mick rook nonetheless

Yikes. No thanks

Image quality is actually solid but the centering and tilt hurt the eye appeal.

This one looks like it was someone's favorite card and they shoved it in their pocket every day to bring to school for a full month. Love that. But as far as EA goes, this is not it.

Huge creases and rounded corners are a major eye sore. The color quality keeps this above an F for me.

Iconic card but unfortunately it has corner issues in top right and bottom right and has the lines thru out and in areas like the face that are highly distracting it. It is also off center

The tilt, centering, and myriad of creases cap this card at a D, for me.

A card that didn’t have a chance from day 1 given the poor centering and extreme tilt when it was placed in the pack at the factory. This card lived a hard life but is no less iconic despite the poor condition. A survivor that could tell some war stories no doubt.

Terrible centering, creases through his face and hat, severe corner wear this copy has very weak eye appeal to me.