1932 U.s. Caramel Lefty Grove #27

Centered & natural wear. Attractive card

gorgeous grove

This copy works for me. There are some flaws, but there’s enough here to bring the overall presentation to a very nice place.

Centered very well. The surface issues on the right side of the card are more noticeable because the left side is so clean. Nice looking card overall.

The focused face holds my attention and then my eyes become aware of great centering. Then the corner wear hits. Then I see some dots of white in the red, which don't bother me. Corner wear is the flaw that dampens eye appeal for me and that's really it.

Very well-centered. The right side of the red background has some snow surface issues.

Borderline A-, I am admittedly on the fence there. The overall look works for me, centering, the red, the focus. The corner wear or the toning in the borders alone would land this in the A Tier. I'll call it a high B+, strong eye appeal.

nice looking card with good color and image but looks like the patina of time has caught up with this card especially on the borders

Great example of the A- badge for me. The eye appeal is strong overall, and the flaws are there but just not jarring enough to leave the top tier.