1933 World Wide Gum Jimmy Foxx #29

Beautifully centered but the dull color brings down the appeal

Great reg, scan looks a little saturated, improving colors (PSA holders aren't blue is what bothers me here). Yellow is a bit too dirty to be better.

Surface is the main issue for me here. The rest of the card is great.

Surface soiling is the issue for me, corner wear like this doesn't faze me or take eye appeal down too much. Love the centering and focus.

Nice centering but the surface and corners drag it down a little for me. Overall, nice card.

Centering is good. There is quite a bit of dirt on the surface and the lower left corner has an issue not present on the other three.

The only flaw that speaks to me here is the surface/dirt that comes with time. The centering, image, absence of any glaring wrinkle or PD, it's all great. Corner wear is at the level where I look right past it.

Great centering, just the surface impacts eye appeal.

This centering is fantastic. The surface brightness level is really my only issue with the visual appeal.

The card presents as a net neutral. It has no real eye appeal to me but all the opportunities are culmination of minor things that add up.