1958 Menko Jackie Robinson #4560

A+ Color A+ Registration / Surface A+ Cut / Centering (hand cut) note: All Menko Jackie cards I’ve seen have some color fade near the middle area of the card. The soft corner showing white will be aesthetically minimized from 24” away. Eye Appeal Wise = God Tier

You don't see many of these, so it's almost hard to critique. I can't imagine the paper loss on the top corners getting much better than this. Special card that to the eye, presents in special condition.

Excellent example of this card, the corner/edge wear is the only item preventing it from being higher. My kind of card.

As I've written on other examples of this card, this is just a card where its inherent design makes it look great--and it takes serious eye appeal problems to take the viewing enjoyment factor down. Here all I can see is the top left corner, in terms of problems. And it's a small problem at that. It would take something glaring on his face or in the background for me to drop the eye appeal factor on this issue.

This is the best example for the grade of the super scare 1958 Menko Doyusha JCM30a Jackie Robinson. Eye appeal does not truly matter when you own a card like this, but this one has it in spades. Due to the hand cut nature of this set, there are often parts of other cards that can be seen on each edge. However, you cannot see any of those flaws on this copy. The card is also a bigger size, and the "Dodgers" is fully visible at the bottom. The color of this one is a rich pink-red hue. I wish I owned this example!

Sharp image and sharp colors only real issues is the corners. Love the styling of this card

The corner wear, especially the upper left jumps at me. Some light fading in the red background as well. Still a very nice card.