1958 Menko Jackie Robinson #4560

1 / 2
Jackie Robinson
💬

Reviews & Discussions

16 total reviews

p_baseball_14
p_baseball_14 COUNCIL A+ 9/20/2025

This is so sweet it made me look into and read up on this card. The faint black mark in top right is all my eye sees after several seconds of happy staring in terms of any eye appeal drawback. Extremely eye-pleasing card.

spacebearcards
spacebearcards COUNCIL GOD TIER 9/19/2025

High eye appeal on this example. Edges are excellent, corners are sharp, and print registration is nearly flawless; the tiny blotch near the cap is inconsequential to my eyes. Confident, clean, and visually cohesive from edge to portrait. This is God Tier.

calvindog
calvindog COUNCIL A- 9/18/2025

Don't love the mark in the background and the wavy top border, but still really nice.

schneidscardstash
schneidscardstash COUNCIL GOD TIER 9/18/2025

Just coming off the review of a much lesser copy.. This is mind blowing in every way. God Tier

mlormer-collection
mlormer-collection COUNCIL GOD TIER 9/18/2025

GT. The end.

dchase
dchase COUNCIL A+ 8/13/2025

Stunner with a little bit of surface issues

jlee_sportscardslive
jlee_sportscardslive COUNCIL A 8/12/2025

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL GOD TIER 8/12/2025

What is there to say?

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL A+ 8/6/2025

love the look of the this card and this corners are sharp and colors strong. Rare Card with Strong Eye Appeal

jackies_and_jordans
jackies_and_jordans COUNCIL GOD TIER 8/6/2025

One of the greatest cards in existence. God Tier.

10 reviews
A
6 reviews

EyeQ+

117.0
Global Population
4
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
#3
Population in Grade
1
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
#1

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

Global Badge Level 3
3rd Place
GLOBAL
In-Grade Badge Level 1
1st Place
IN-GRADE
📊

Rating Distribution

16 total reviews

G
5 ratings
50%
5
A+
3 ratings
30%
3
A
1 rating
10%
1
A-
1 rating
10%
1
B+
0%
B
0%
B-
0%
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%