1958 Menko Jackie Robinson #4560

1 / 2
Jackie Robinson
💬

Reviews & Discussions

6 total reviews

underthebat_
underthebat_ COUNCIL B 12/27/2025

Cool card. Edge damage and corners hold it back from A tier.

dchase
dchase COUNCIL B- 8/22/2025

I would take this card if it was run over by a truck five times and ripped in half. Even though the edges are discolored and corners are a mess, it is special.

jrock1956topps
jrock1956topps COUNCIL B 8/14/2025

It is difficult to assess borders on hand-cut cards like this one, but these look very nice. On a pack issued card, the left edge would like result in a mis-cut designation, but I do not believe those same rules should apply to hand-cut cards like this one, which still has great color and nice image clarity. A rare card that looks better to me than the assigned technical grade.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL B- 8/7/2025

Love this Japanese card. This card has no borders but this card edges have noticeably paper lost. And the corners have issues. Also discoloration on back

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL A- 8/4/2025

This is a very striking and unique card; reminds me of a Warhol. Love the color of the background. The Japanese lettering adds great style as well. This specimen really pleases the eye, too. When earnest corner wear is the prime cause for a low third party opinion, that's ideal-- as the surface here is free of any problems. The eye is drawn to his face and the background on this card. Punches way above its third-party weight class, so to speak.

B
5 reviews
B-
1 review

EyeQ+

--
Global Population
4
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
—
No Eye Q+ score
Population in Grade
1
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
—
No Eye Q+ score

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

No Global Trophy
GLOBAL
No In-Grade Trophy
IN-GRADE
Trophies appear here when earned.
📊

Rating Distribution

6 total reviews

G
0%
A+
0%
A
0%
A-
1 rating
20%
1
B+
0%
B
2 ratings
40%
2
B-
2 ratings
40%
2
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%