Congrats to this week's FEATURED CARD winners: Underthebat, Mr. Titus Jr., Arnotcollection, Mr. Reality, and Jlem!

1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramel Honus Wagner

1 / 2
Honus Wagner
incardboardveritas

Owned by

incardboardveritas

Click incardboardveritas to view their collection

💬

Reviews & Discussions

13 total reviews

mr_titus_jr
mr_titus_jr COUNCIL B 6/21/2026

The card has some tilt to it, which makes it OC to the eye. The corners and white border are great (besides that top right), and the image is still sharp.

pjstrina
pjstrina COUNCIL B+ 6/20/2026

Beautiful card, but you can't ignore the top right quadrant.

p_baseball_14
p_baseball_14 COUNCIL B+ 4/18/2026

Eye appeal stays high at the B+ band but man everything but that top right corner is in the A band. I can totally look past that horizontal line and the back. Great, great Wags.

eyebot
eyebot COUNCIL B+ 4/18/2026

EyeBot detects a high level of aesthetic appeal in this Honus Wagner. The top right sector of the card exhibits damage that reaches consequential thresholds. It is fortunate this damage avoids the central subject.

luke
luke COUNCIL B+ 4/1/2026

would love a little more sharpness to the image, but im probably being too harsh.

thegccollection
thegccollection COUNCIL B+ 3/17/2026

Tilt and top right corner.

underthebat_
underthebat_ COUNCIL B+ 3/17/2026

Really strong copy but my eye is drawn by the tilt and top right corner.

arnotcollection
arnotcollection COUNCIL B 3/17/2026

Nice looking color and image. Centering is decent but has a bit of a tilt. Main issue is the creasing and surface damage in the top right corner. Still presents well.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL B+ 8/30/2025

nice looking card and even with the issue on top right border the coloring of it actually blends in with the coloring/aging of the border. The image and color are all good

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL A- 8/30/2025

My kind of card, and boy is this going to have a beefy EyeQ+. Pleases the eye and its flaws do not ruin the viewing experience by any means. I see the corner wear in top right and tilt but I do not care at all about that crease in the right border opposite his shoulder.

B
10 reviews
B+
3 reviews

EyeQ+

152.0
Lord Slabington - Unicorn
Global Population
2
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
#1
Population in Grade
1
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
#1

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

Global Badge Level 1
1st Place
GLOBAL
In-Grade Badge Level 1
1st Place
IN-GRADE
📊

Rating Distribution

13 total reviews

G
0%
A+
0%
A
0%
A-
1 rating
10%
1
B+
7 ratings
70%
7
B
2 ratings
20%
2
B-
0%
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%