Congrats to this week's FEATURED CARD winners: Underthebat, Mr. Titus Jr., Arnotcollection, Mr. Reality, and Jlem!

1954 Johnston Cookies Henry Aaron #5

1 / 2
Henry Aaron
💬

Reviews & Discussions

8 total reviews

p_baseball_14
p_baseball_14 COUNCIL A+ 2d

This is simply great looking. Buy it and cross it off the list for good! I find this level of corner rounding does not nag my eye at all. Amazing how much it affects number grade versus how little it affects eye appeal.

pjstrina
pjstrina COUNCIL A- 2d

Corners and some yellowing, but this is darn good. Beautiful image.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL A- 3/29/2026

Great card to stand back and just enjoy. With nice size borders and respectable centering and nice image and looks really. Discoloring from aging on this card works and just adds character

underthebat_
underthebat_ COUNCIL A+ 3/29/2026

Beautiful copy that presents exceptionally well. My only note is what looks like some toning, but it blends in nicely with the card's presentation.

jlem
jlem COUNCIL A+ 3/29/2026

Hard to find anything wrong with this card. Well-framed. Great Color. Beautiful image. Some mild toning keeps it from GT.

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL A 3/28/2026

This hits my eye great. Nothing disrupts the viewing enjoyment. Gentle corner wear is all I can cite and it makes only a mild impact on eye appeal. Image + centering are my keys and this has'em.

A
6 reviews
A
2 reviews

EyeQ+

--
Global Population
2
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
—
No Eye Q+ score
Population in Grade
1
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
—
No Eye Q+ score

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

No Global Trophy
GLOBAL
No In-Grade Trophy
IN-GRADE
Trophies appear here when earned.
📊

Rating Distribution

8 total reviews

G
0%
A+
3 ratings
50%
3
A
1 rating
17%
1
A-
2 ratings
33%
2
B+
0%
B
0%
B-
0%
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%