1960 Topps Ernie Banks #10

What I have learned to call a "fish eye" is the flaw to which I assign the most weight, in the case of this Banks. Centering is a mild secondary concern. All else is of high-order visual appeal.

Nice eye appeal to me on this one driven by color, sharp registration, and an exceptionally clean, consistent surface. The image displays with crisp detail and freshness, creating a vibrant presentation to my eye. A fish eye within the nameplate and centering that falls just short of ideal are noticeable, holding the example back slightly from an even higher level.

Clean color & attractive centering

Nice-looking card with strong color to me. Centering could be improved, and what looks like a small fisheye in the green is a bit distracting.

This is A- all day without that dot near the S in BANKS. Remains a high eye appeal grade for me because it's really pretty even with the side centering being a bit off.

Beautiful colors and image. The fisheye on the bottom right and centering are the main issues.

Fish eye and very mild centering are the only issues. Strong eye appeal overall.

Color looks great and the card is clean. Top to bottom centering and a fish eye after his name are the only issues I see.

Some might look really really close and see off centering left to right. But so subtle and with it being a horizontal card no biggie. Then you add in a nice clean card with nice image and colors and you get satisfaction