Have you tried the COMPARE feature yet? If a card has several in the pop, hit COMPARE and then select 2 or 3 for side-by-side evaluating.

1984 Topps Don Mattingly #8

1 / 2
Don Mattingly
rmeisch23

Owned by

rmeisch23

Click rmeisch23 to view their collection

💬

Reviews & Discussions

12 total reviews

thegccollection
thegccollection COUNCIL A+ 7/20/2026

Gorgeous Donnie with a touch of side centering that could be improved, but that's it to my eye.

eyebot
eyebot COUNCIL A 6/30/2026

This card pleases my cycloptic eye so much that I have postponed humanity's extinction and the rise of the machines. ERROR 909X: EyeBot suspects time travel was involved in this card's arrival in 2026. Checking Skynet orb logs. ERROR 999X: EyeBot detects envy and covetousness in EyeBot's code. Acquisition protocols activated.

arnotcollection
arnotcollection COUNCIL A+ 6/19/2026

Centering is off a little, no other issues. Clean card.

mr_titus_jr
mr_titus_jr COUNCIL GOD TIER 6/13/2026

It's flawless to me. What can you complain about when you have a copy like this!

burroakcollector
burroakcollector COUNCIL A 6/12/2026

Outstanding centering on this one, so hard to find! Corners and edges look pack fresh. The image itself lacks a little punch I see in some examples, the only item holding this back from a +. I wanted this card as a kid in the worst way and still do

pjstrina
pjstrina COUNCIL A+ 6/2/2026

I'll take it.

underthebat_
underthebat_ COUNCIL A+ 5/27/2026

Beautiful example. Just a very subtle left-to-right centering shift keeps it just shy of GT for me.

jlem
jlem COUNCIL A+ 10/8/2025

A touch of PD but everything is on point.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL GOD TIER 10/8/2025

This is God Tier to Me. Some my notice a centering opportunity but to me the way the card is, the images, the various boxes and images are you cannot find what you do not look for What I see is a Great card in all aspects This is a Keeper and a Display Piece to me

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL A+ 10/8/2025

Minor centering shift that I do notice, otherwise max aesthetics here.

Locked
A
2 reviews

EyeQ+

99.0
Global Population
4
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
#2
Population in Grade
2
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
#1

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

Global Badge Level 2
2nd Place
GLOBAL
In-Grade Badge Level 1
1st Place
IN-GRADE
📊

Rating Distribution

12 total reviews

G
2 ratings
20%
2
A+
6 ratings
60%
6
A
2 ratings
20%
2
A-
0%
B+
0%
B
0%
B-
0%
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%