1909 E90-1 American Caramel Cy Young

Those borders really impress and overshadow other flaws. I could make an analogy to human traits and attractiveness but you guys get it!

Really nice centering and borders. The surface issues around his face hold it back for me.

Those are some BEEFY borders! The flaws on Old Cy are there and definitely hurt the eye appeal, but this card has something.

I want to love this card so much because the centering and jumbo borders charm the heck out of me-- the print issues on Cy knock it out of the top echelon, however. I would still really enjoy this card in my collection.

So many yellow spots and it effects both the image and the color quality and it hurts the overall eye appeal and it is a shame as the nice size borders and brightness of the card has some appeal that is held back

Very well-centered with slight tilt. Good image but the yellow spots in the red background and also through the face hurts the eye-appeal for me.