1909 E90-1 American Caramel Cy Young

Just the centering for me.

Looks like he's staring out his window and we sneezed while taking his photo so our camera shifted left at the last moment.

Everything is so outstanding except for centering, which is extreme enough to land eye appeal at the B Tier. That said, I never thought I could like a card this much with such off centering!

The print registration here is truly outstanding. The red pops beautifully, especially in the hair, and it plays perfectly against the clean white jersey, giving the image a sharp, high-contrast look that feels almost too good for the issue. But the centering is the stumbling block. It’s the one thing that keeps this card from feeling fully composed, and if you’re sensitive to centering, it’s impossible to unsee. Picky or not, it’s a fair critique on an otherwise spectacular looking card.

Almost a B+ for me, that is how nice the registration and color are. The centering that level would normally mean C Tier yet this one breaks that rule of mine!

So much to like about the card from color, image, and brightness But that off centering is to much for me especially with so many of this card out there with better borders/centering

I really like the image and the clean red background. T/B centering is right on. L/R centering is the main issue that detracts from the eye-appeal a bit.