1909 American Caramel Cy Young

Great color and centering. The whiting on the face and print line on the bottom middle distract slightly from an otherwise beautiful example of this iconic card

This card has it where it counts, is how I'd put it.

I like this Cy. The centering and the red plus the focused image do the trick. I don't mind the strike marks at the bottom. The back is not something I ever really care about.

Print line is first noted followed by some surface scuffing, most notably near his face, but well centered and nice colors. The reverse keeps it in the B tier for me.

The centering and image look very nice. Fairly clean red background. Not the biggest fan of printer marks.

Yes, please! I love this card and have always wanted one. What I look for is clean red, no issues within it, obviously no problems on Cy, and then ideally centering. This example checks all those boxes. Printers' marks don't cause too much of a stir to my eyes. For me, backs are a non issue. So this would be one for me.

condition issues stand out to hold the card back. The Red is really sharp and it has nice border sizes. But toning on card, the issues at bottom and the border wear hurt