1939 Play Ball Ted Williams #92

The image quality and crispness stand out to me. The centering looks like the main thing that holds it back.

EyeBot determines that Eye Appeal remains squarely in the respectable second tier, as the central image of Teddy Ballgame is enjoyable with only two small "fisheyes" that do not sabotage the viewing experience. Centering creates enough visual imbalance to restrict access to the highest tier of badges.

Image: A. Surface: A. Edges/corners: B. Good eye appeal with centering being what is keeping it in the B Tier.

I love the quality of the image and the pose. Demerits for the centering.

Obvious shift to the left but otherwise strong print & contrast. Very nice.

The centering bothers me personally, but besides that, it maintains decent eye appeal.

Strong image. Off-centered with some surface blemishes in the background.

Solid second tier example with a strong image and surface; centering is the obvious issue that impacts a bit.

love the image and the clarity of it. Surface is mostly clean except minor imperfections but they blend in real well. The borders are the issue as they do not frame the image well and centering is off. But the image helps prop it up

Image looks good. There is some minor surface wear but centering is the main issue.