1948 Leaf Stan Musial #4

I'm torn here because the auto is just so great. Such a cool card. But the tape stains and centering hurt the eye appeal. I'm gonna throw a dart in the middle of an A+ auto and a D+ card and call it a B-

This card doesn't do it for me on the appeal standard. As a collector, having this Leaf signed is great in its own right.

The blue on blue works better than you’d think

I kind of dig the auto/card's monochrome aesthetic. General wear, staining, and centering have heavy impact but it just stays in the second tier for my taste on a signed RC.

The auto is nice and bold but it's the same color as the background and blends in a little. The card has some serious surface issues, but the overall look still works for me.

great to have the card with the auto but this is not the one i would enjoy as much as i could. The card has condition issues and the auto blends to much into the background of the card

Beautiful auto. Centering and staining hold it back.